Eratherm İzolasyon A.Ş.
Tender · Bid Evaluation · Qualification

Owner's Engineering for Insulation Tenders and Technical Bid Evaluation

The insulation package is usually tendered late, priced fast and evaluated on total price. That is where the money is lost, because the cheapest bid is almost always the one that assumed the least scope. ERATHERM acts as the owner's engineer through the tender: we write or review the tender specification, qualify the bidders technically, evaluate the bids clause by clause, run the clarification round and build the approved material list, so the award is made on comparable scope rather than on three different interpretations of the same document. We work worldwide, in EPC-level English.

Tender specificationTechnical bid evaluationContractor qualificationApproved material list
Owner's engineering review of industrial insulation tender documents and bids
20+ yearsEngineering and contracting experience
8 million+Man-hours of site experience
1,000,000+ m²Completed insulation application
3 continentsProject delivery
Scope

Six owner's engineering packages across the tender cycle

Each package below can be taken on its own. The input we need and the decision you get out of it are defined before the engagement starts.

01

Tender specification preparation

A specification that can be priced without assumptions: scope boundaries, measurement rules, materials by property, workmanship, inspection regime and documentation requirements.

02

Bidder list and qualification

Technical qualification of contractors against manpower, supervision, previous comparable scope, quality system, HSE record and the ability to mobilise in the project country.

03

Technical bid evaluation

Bid by bid comparison against the specification, with exceptions, qualifications and assumed scope identified and normalised so the prices become comparable.

04

Clarification management

Technical queries issued and tracked, answers distributed to all bidders on equal terms, and the effect of each answer on the price recorded.

05

Approved material list

Material families and compliant manufacturers approved on technical grounds, with the evidence required for a substitution defined in advance.

06

Award recommendation

A scored technical recommendation with the commercial normalisation set out, the residual risks named and the conditions that should be carried into the contract.

Conflict of interest

Where ERATHERM may bid for the execution of the same scope, we either decline the owner's engineering role or are excluded from the bidder list in writing, at your choice.

Technical bid evaluation of industrial insulation tenders
Why bids differ

Three bids, three different scopes, one price comparison

Insulation bids rarely differ because one contractor is cheaper. They differ because one measured the scope net and another gross, one allowed for scaffolding and another did not, one priced the specified material and another a substitute.

Evaluation starts by making the scopes identical on paper. Only after normalisation does the price difference mean anything, and in our experience the ranking changes more often than it stays the same.

  • Scope normalised before prices are compared
  • Exceptions and qualifications listed bid by bid
  • Measurement basis checked against the stated rules
  • Scaffolding, access and interface allowances made visible
Deliverables

What you receive at each stage

Produced under your document control procedure, in EPC-level English, revision controlled.

Tender document set

Specification, drawings, bill of quantities, pricing schedule and bidder questionnaire.

Qualification report

Bidder assessment against technical, quality, HSE and capacity criteria.

Bid evaluation report

Clause by clause comparison, exceptions register and normalised price basis.

Clarification log

Queries, answers, issue dates and the price effect of each clarification.

Approved material list

Approved families and manufacturers with the technical basis and substitution route.

Award recommendation

Scored ranking, residual risk register and the conditions to carry into contract.

Owner's engineering site supervision during insulation execution
After award

The same discipline through execution

An award made on a normalised scope still has to be held there. We review the contractor's method statements and material submittals, witness the hold points agreed in the inspection and test plan, and assess variation claims against the tender basis we wrote.

Progress is measured against the quantities as measured, not as claimed, and the documentation required for acceptance is tracked from the first week rather than assembled at handover.

  • Method statement and submittal review
  • Witness points attended and recorded
  • Variation claims assessed against the tender basis
  • Progress measurement and quality file tracking
Engagement types

Six ways owners use us depending on the stage

The role changes with the phase of the project. Each engagement below has a different deliverable and a different level of involvement.

Budget stage

Independent quantity take-off and cost estimate before the scope is committed.

Tender preparation

Specification, bill of quantities and tender documentation ready for issue.

Bid evaluation

Technical evaluation, clarification management and award recommendation.

Design review

Review of the contractor's or EPC's insulation design against the specification.

Execution supervision

Hold point attendance, submittal review, progress measurement and quality file control.

Dispute and claim support

Technical assessment of variation claims, defect causes and remedial scope.

Industrial plant insulation scope under owner's engineering supervision
Where it pays

The insulation package is small until it is not

Insulation is typically a low percentage of plant capital cost and a high percentage of avoidable energy loss. A specification that buys the wrong thickness commits the plant to that loss for its operating life, and no amount of maintenance recovers it.

The second cost is slower: a system that traps moisture produces corrosion under insulation, and the repair happens during a turnaround, at turnaround rates, on equipment that cannot be taken out of service any other time.

  • Energy loss committed at specification stage, not at operation
  • Corrosion risk decided by vapour barrier and detailing choices
  • Turnaround repair cost far above original installation cost
  • Measurable payback assessed before the scope is committed
Qualified insulation team executing work under an EPC contract
Credibility

We have been on the other side of the table

We have delivered insulation scope as a contractor on refinery, petrochemical and power projects for two decades, with our own qualified and certified personnel and without ever using a subcontractor.

That is why the evaluation is realistic. We know which allowances a bidder has left out, which productivity figures cannot be achieved in that access, and which clauses are routinely priced at zero and claimed later.

  • Contracting experience on EPC-level insulation packages
  • Realistic productivity and allowance benchmarks
  • Claim patterns recognised before they are submitted
  • Over 1,000,000 m² of completed application behind the judgement

Industrial Insulation Catalogue

Engineering scope, calculation and documentation services, material families and application capability in a single document.

Open the 2026 catalogue

Working worldwide

ERATHERM works as an engineering partner for operators, EPC contractors and equipment manufacturers. Calculation, design, documentation and specification work is delivered remotely under the client's document control procedure; inspection, site supervision and application teams are mobilised to site.

  • Europe, the Middle East, Asia, Africa and the Americas
  • EPC-level deliverable documentation
  • Client document control procedure
  • Remote engineering and site mobilisation
Frequently asked

Owner's engineering and bid evaluation

Can you evaluate bids on a specification you did not write?

Yes. We evaluate against whatever document was issued, and the first output is usually a list of the clauses in that document that allowed the bidders to differ. That list is also the basis for the clarification round.

How do you handle a conflict of interest?

Either ERATHERM is excluded from the bidder list in writing, or we decline the owner's engineering role. The choice is yours and it is made before the engagement starts, not after the bids arrive.

Do you give a commercial recommendation as well?

We normalise the technical scope and set out the commercial consequence of each exception. The commercial decision stays with you; our recommendation is scored on technical compliance, capacity and risk.

What is an approved material list for?

It separates the specification from the market. The specification states properties and test methods; the approved material list names the families and manufacturers that meet them, and can be revised when availability changes without reissuing the specification.

Can you support an ongoing dispute?

Yes. We assess variation claims and defect causes against the contract documents and the physical evidence, and issue a technical opinion with the measurement and calculation behind it.

What do you need to start a bid evaluation?

The issued tender documents, the bids as received including all qualifications and exceptions, the correspondence to date, and your evaluation criteria if they are already fixed.

Send us the tender before you issue it

We will tell you which clauses will be priced around, what the bids will differ on, and what the evaluation will need in order to compare them on the same scope.